Talk:Cluny the Scourge
Back to page
Contents |
Whip
Edit
Would it be alright to add that a scourge was a whip used for punishment and that maybe Brian Jaques had this in mind when naming Cluny? (Ps, thanx to LPG for that info) -- Old Saint Merlock Merry CHRISTmas 17:56, December 20, 2009 (UTC)
- Adding what a "scourge" is under trivia would be acceptable. -- LordTBT
Talk! 02:00, December 28, 2009 (UTC)
AccentEdit
How did Cluny have a Spanish/Portugese accent in the book? That's under trivia but I never really noticed that. --Long Patrol Girl 
"Fish and Chips!!" 03:44, March 16, 2010 (UTC)
SourceEdit
Here's the source. This is from the 2nd page of the Q&A section on his website.
- Q. I recently looked up 'Cluny' in the American Heritage Dictionary, and discovered that it is a town in east central France. It features an Abbey founded in 910 AD, the home of an influential religious order (!). Is this where you got Cluny's name? It's pretty ironic.
- A. I thought Cluny sounded a little like Looney and as he is a mad type that seemed to suit him. It wasn't until some time later that I found out about the Abbey in France. It did seem a little spooky to me too!
Sorry I didn't put this in the talk page earlier.--Gandr Adderbane Slayer of Snakes 20:18, March 16, 2010 (UTC)
Only Villain to Conquer?Edit
I think that the part about Cluny being the only villain to conquer Redwall should be changed, as General Ironbeak came as close.--The Wild One
Today is a good day to die! 03:08, June 19, 2010 (UTC)
- "Close" only counts in horseshoes and handgrenades.--Gandr Adderbane Slayer of Snakes 11:14, June 19, 2010 (UTC)
- The only major villains to actually enter Redwall were Cluny, Ironbeak, the Marlfoxes (I forgot which ones), Badredd, Raga Bol, and Zwilt the Shade.
Thornclaw --There's a difference between being a stoat and a vermin...and I proved it to the world. 13:46, June 19, 2010 (UTC)
- So then shouldn't that be erased? The NightThe King of randomness Stands here! 16:45, June 25, 2010 (UTC)
- I think it should. The statement "Cluny is also famous for being the only character to successfully overtake the Abbey" doesn't seem accurate. I agree with Snowpaw, Ironbeak DID successfully capture the abbey. He just didn't hold it anywhere near as long. Both of them conquered all the inhabitants. In the case of Cluney, it was Matthias and a bunch of outsiders who took it back. In the case of Ironbeak, it was that huge red bird who happened to be randomly lurking in the wine celler (convenient). I can't help but wonder too: since Slagar had everyone asleep, couldn't he have tied everyone up or simply killed them while they were drugged as he did the two who didn't drink his drugged wine? Ty 03:02, July 21, 2010 (UTC)
Physical skillEdit
- "He is one of the few villain leaders whose physical skill exceeds the hero, leading to his death by means of the Joseph Bell."
This sounds kind of vague. How few is 'few'? Is 'the hero' indicating Matthias, or whoever the main character or hero of a respective novel happens to be? Like, for example, you could argue that Matthias is still the hero in Mattimeo perhaps, but one could also take the perception that Mattimeo is the hero (being the namesake) and in that case, Slagar clearly surpasses Mattimeo in skill (and possibly even Matthias or Orlando, that never came to a conclusion). The same of Malkariss since we never got to see his full fighting abilities. Even though he was old, he was still some kind of cat and he was defeated by falling rocks, and he was injured in the fall so we don't know if he might have dodged the rocks or defeated Matthias in prime condition.
Another thing is: it's not like the Joseph Bell jumped down and defeated Cluny on its own, Matthias cut the rope after all. To me, that's an extension of his physical skills, it is him using his brain and his fast swordplay as well as reflexes to jump out of the way. If we start discounting the environment or tools as 'physical skill' then we may as well say something like "the adder exceeded the hero's physical skill, leading to his death by means of Martin's Sword". Ty 03:02, July 21, 2010 (UTC)
Another question Edit
I'm just curios where does it say he's a bilge rat oh must of missed it —This unsigned comment was added by 173.81.53.43 (talk • contribs) 01:16, February 28, 2011. Please sign your posts with ~~~~!
- The very first page that describes him. Did you even look? -- LordTBT Talk! 01:23, February 28, 2011 (UTC)
Cluny Abbey Edit
I recently discovered that there is actually an abbey in France called Cluny Abbey. I was wondering if it might be worth it to mention this as another possible origin for his name. Coldclaw 23:16, May 24, 2011 (UTC)
- Nope, it's not. If you'll see Ask Brian at Redwall.org, Mr. Jacques states this is just a coincidence. -- LordTBT Talk! 23:47, May 24, 2011 (UTC)
BarbaricEdit
Cluny the Scourge is a brilliant barbaric strategist!Wedgeback 14:41, January 16, 2012 (UTC)
Would it be worth mentioning that both he and Vilaya and primary weapons that used poison? Or would it be redundant as poison is used a lot among vermin?-Segalia Riverstorm, Archer Ottermaid Warrior 
Do that again and I kill you 22:23, February 17, 2012 (UTC)
Cluny Edit
Although Redwall does state that Cluny the Scourge could've been a Portuguese Rat, it never mentions him being from Portugal. Isn't it a bit rash to say that as a possibility when it never directly mentions that possibility?
Forest-F.FThe shadow slayers will come for you!! 18:53, July 6, 2012 (UTC)
- That is the first definition of Portuguese certainly, and I think it applies. I'll alter it though. -- LordTBT Talk! 23:22, July 6, 2012 (UTC)
- Okay, yeah. That looks better. I've another question though. How is it that the picture of Cluny from the 1996 Redwall Diary is allowed on here, while you have misgivings about the uploading of pictures from the Mossflower Collectors edition? I'm not persisting to have them uploaded, but I'm curious as to why one can stay on RW while others are not allowed on.
- Forest-F.FThe shadow slayers will come for you!! 03:50, July 7, 2012 (UTC)
