Redwall Wiki


Thornclaw's Redwall Book Awards

In this I talk about different Redwall books and give or take points from each because of a certain topic or event. We'll see how good I personally think each book has been by the end. Every book starts with 5 points because it's a Redwall book.


+2 points because it was the book that started this whole series.

-3 because Abbot Mortimer is annoying.

+2 because Basil Stag Hare is great.

-3 because the whole Abbey acts too religious, and BJ has mentioned it too many times: Redwall has no religion!

+3 because Warbeak is great.

-4 because it got boring towards the end.

I guess that's it. That leaves you with a total of 2 points. Not much, I admit, but wait until you see the others!


+2 points because Gonff is awesome.

-2 points because Tsarmina broke Martin's sword.

+4 points because Skipper Warthorn is cool.

-2 because the journey to Salamandastron was boring.

+2 because Bane was cool.

+4 because Boar the Fighter was awesome.

+2 because Martin got a new sword.

-5 because the battle against Ripfang was too short.

-5 because Martin almost died.

+1 because I knew Sunflash had made it to Salamandastron.

That gives you 6 points.


+3 because Matthias is getting better.

-2 because Vitch is annoying.

+4 because Basil Stag Hare is getting better.

+3 because Slagar is awesome.

-4 because Mattimeo and Co. were captured.

+2 because Orlando the Axe is cool.

-1 because the Painted Ones should have been portrayed better.

-3 because Matthias lost the fight with Wearet.

+4 because the Blackrobes are awesome.

-5 because they killed off Warbeak.

That's a total of 6 points again.

Mariel of Redwall

+4 because Rawnblade is awesome.

-2 because Bludrigg and Saltar were annoying.

Ad blocker interference detected!

Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.

Also on Fandom

Random Wiki