In this I talk about different Redwall books and give or take points from each because of a certain topic or event. We'll see how good I personally think each book has been by the end. Every book starts with 5 points because it's a Redwall book.
+2 points because it was the book that started this whole series.
-3 because Abbot Mortimer is annoying.
+2 because Basil Stag Hare is great.
-3 because the whole Abbey acts too religious, and BJ has mentioned it too many times: Redwall has no religion!
+3 because Warbeak is great.
-4 because it got boring towards the end.
I guess that's it. That leaves you with a total of 2 points. Not much, I admit, but wait until you see the others!
+2 points because Gonff is awesome.
-2 points because Tsarmina broke Martin's sword.
+4 points because Skipper Warthorn is cool.
-2 because the journey to Salamandastron was boring.
+2 because Bane was cool.
+4 because Boar the Fighter was awesome.
+2 because Martin got a new sword.
-5 because the battle against Ripfang was too short.
-5 because Martin almost died.
+1 because I knew Sunflash had made it to Salamandastron.
That gives you 6 points.
+3 because Matthias is getting better.
-2 because Vitch is annoying.
+4 because Basil Stag Hare is getting better.
+3 because Slagar is awesome.
-4 because Mattimeo and Co. were captured.
+2 because Orlando the Axe is cool.
-1 because the Painted Ones should have been portrayed better.
-3 because Matthias lost the fight with Wearet.
+4 because the Blackrobes are awesome.
-5 because they killed off Warbeak.
That's a total of 6 points again.
Mariel of Redwall
+4 because Rawnblade is awesome.
-2 because Bludrigg and Saltar were annoying.